Book a meeting
All articles
Hiring Practice22 November 2026·6 min read

29% of Australia's Occupations Are in Shortage. Here's How to Run Selection When You Hire Nearly Every Applicant.

A shortage raises your selection ratio toward 1.0, which collapses the value of ranking candidates but not the value of assessing them. A seven-step redesign, grounded in OECD and Jobs and Skills Australia shortage data and the Taylor-Russell selection tables.

By AssessAll Editorial

A shortage occupation is one where employers cannot fill vacancies at prevailing wages and conditions despite genuine recruiting effort. It is a statement about a labour market, not about any candidate in front of you. A shortage pushes your selection ratio — the share of applicants you hire — toward 1.0. That changes what your assessment is for. It does not remove the need for one.

Most teams respond to a shortage by quietly lowering the bar and hoping. The better response is to change the job the assessment is doing — and to document that you did.

What a shortage list actually measures

On 14 October 2026 the OECD published Mapping Skill Shortages in OECD Countries, the third edition of its Skills for Jobs database, covering 38 countries. Its pattern finding is that shortages concentrate in high-skilled work — ICT specialists, science and engineering professionals, health professionals and teachers — while lower-skilled occupations more often show surpluses.

National lists tell the same story with harder edges. Jobs and Skills Australia's 2025 Occupation Shortage List assessed 29% of occupations as being in shortage, down from 33% in 2024 and 36% in 2023. Nearly half of trade occupations and two in five professional occupations remained short, concentrated in health, education and construction.

Vacancy data points the same way. Eurostat put the euro area job vacancy rate at 2.1% in Q3 2025 and the EU rate at 2.0%, both down from 2.5% and 2.3% a year earlier.

Read together, the honest summary is that pressure has eased from its peak while a substantial minority of occupations remain hard to fill. But every one of these numbers is a market aggregate. A shortage list tells you the queue outside your door is short. It tells you nothing about whether the person at the front of it can do the work.

The arithmetic that makes people give up on assessment

Your selection ratio is hires divided by applicants. The classic reference is Taylor and Russell's selection tables (Taylor, H. C., & Russell, J. T., 1939, Journal of Applied Psychology, 23(5), 565–578), which show the proportion of hires who turn out satisfactory at a given predictor validity, base rate and selection ratio.

Take a base rate of .50 — half your current people are performing acceptably — and a predictor validity of .50. The tables give:

  • Selection ratio .10 (you hire 1 in 10): .84 of hires satisfactory
  • Selection ratio .30: .74
  • Selection ratio .50: .67
  • Selection ratio .95 (you hire nearly everyone): .52

That last row is what makes hiring managers abandon testing in a shortage. If you must hire 95 of every 100 applicants, a good test moves your success rate from .50 to .52, and the effort looks unjustifiable.

The arithmetic is correct. The inference is wrong, for a specific reason: those tables price one function only — ranking a queue to pick the best of it. That is the function a shortage destroys. It is not the only function an assessment has.

Three jobs your assessment still does when you hire nearly everyone

Establishing minimum competence. At a selection ratio of .95 you still reject 5%. Identifying which 5% is a real decision with real consequences, and it is a pass/fail judgement against a standard, not a ranking exercise. The distinction matters: a norm-referenced percentile tells you who is best in a thin applicant pool, which in a shortage can mean "best of three people who all fall short."

Producing a gap profile. If you are hiring someone who would have failed your old bar, the useful output is not a score but a specific list of what they cannot yet do — an onboarding input. AI-graded scenario assessments suit this well, because they produce reasoning-level detail rather than a single number.

Creating a defensible record. Lowering a cut score under hiring pressure gets examined later — sometimes by a regulator, sometimes by your own leadership after a bad cohort. A documented standard, change and rationale are what separate a deliberate adjustment from drift.

How to redesign selection for a shortage role

1. Confirm it is a shortage, not your own funnel

Before accepting a market explanation, rule out the cheaper ones: an uncompetitive wage, a description listing twelve requirements for a role that needs four, internal approval delay, or an application process candidates abandon midway. A shortage you created is fixable this quarter; a national one is not.

2. Measure your actual selection ratio

Not the market's — yours, for this role, over the last two quarters: qualified applicants reaching final decision, divided by offers extended. Teams routinely assume .20 while operating at .80.

3. Split the requirement into day-one and trainable

Run a short job analysis that sorts each requirement into "must be present on day one" and "can be brought to standard within 90 days." A shortage is a reason to move items into the second bucket deliberately, with a named owner and a re-assessment date. It is not a reason to pretend the items do not exist.

4. Re-derive the cut score rather than nudging it

The US Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures state at §1607.5(H) that where cutoff scores are used they should normally be set to be reasonable and consistent with normal expectations of acceptable proficiency within the workforce. That is a standard-setting instruction, and "normal expectations" can legitimately differ for a role you intend to train into.

The same section is useful in another way. §1607.5(G) holds that ranking requires stronger validity and utility evidence than pass/fail use when ranking produces greater adverse impact. In a shortage you are moving away from ranking anyway — which also moves you toward the lower evidentiary burden. The SIOP Principles (5th ed., 2018) and the Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing both treat cut-score setting as a documented judgement process, not a number inherited from a vendor.

5. Re-run the adverse impact check after the change

A changed cut score changes impact ratios, sometimes in the direction you want and sometimes not. Repeat the check on the new rule rather than carrying it over.

6. Widen the geography, then verify before pooling scores

Opening a role to a second country is the most common structural fix for a thin funnel, and it raises a measurement question at once: scores from two markets are not comparable just because they came from the same instrument. Establish that before applying one cut score to both.

7. Track the below-bar cohort

Record who was hired under the relaxed standard and compare their 6- and 12-month performance and attrition against hires above the old bar. This is the only way the next adjustment is evidence-based rather than another guess.

The checklist

  1. Rule out wage, job description, process delay and drop-off as causes.
  2. Compute your real selection ratio for this role.
  3. Sort requirements into day-one versus trainable-in-90-days.
  4. Re-set the cut score as a documented standard-setting decision.
  5. Switch from ranking to pass/fail against that standard.
  6. Re-run the adverse impact analysis on the new rule.
  7. Verify score comparability before pooling candidates across markets.
  8. Assign training owners and re-assessment dates for every deferred requirement.
  9. Review the below-bar cohort's outcomes at 6 and 12 months.

Running a pilot on one shortage role is inexpensive to test: AssessAll's pay-as-you-go credits are ₹30 or US$0.50 per assessment, with 100 free credits on individual signup and 250 on corporate signup, which is enough to check whether a gap profile tells you anything your interview did not.

When this redesign is the wrong move

If your selection ratio is genuinely low — more qualified applicants than seats — none of the above applies, and the Taylor-Russell logic runs the other way: ranking is exactly what you should do, and a more valid predictor is worth paying for. If the role carries a hard regulatory or safety floor, there is no trainable bucket, and the right answer is to leave the seat empty rather than re-derive a cut score. Shortage lists are also lagging indicators, published annually against earlier data.

Takeaway

A shortage does not make assessment pointless — it changes the assessment's job from ranking a queue to certifying a floor and mapping what to train. The teams that handle shortages well are the ones that make that switch on purpose and write down why.

#skill-shortages#selection-ratio#cut-scores#global-hiring#workforce-planning

Measure it, don't guess it.

Start free with 100 credits — or write to solutions@bodhih.com.

Start free